I'm so glad I just discovered this restaurant. That was hands down the best Cheesesteak I've eaten in Indiana. The meat was tender & well seasoned; the bread was thin, yet soft, warm and delicious. Plus the peppers and onions I had on mine... oof. Just a nice, firm sandwich that held together well; no grease soaking through the buns. I was stoked that it doesn't arrive drowning in grease like many other spots. Just a firm, hot sub with a generous portion of steak on a perfectly sized bun. Their "always-fresh" approach to food prep stands out among any other fastfood place in Anderson. 5/5 stars for that reason.
Try the fries too btw; they literally grab a potato and make em fresh on the spot, even at 9:30pm before they close. They got a neat philosophy to food service there - the wrappers even come with instructions on how to reheat leftovers. It's as if they actually care about how their food tastes.
C
Cindy B
Local Expert • 131 contributions
Loved
• 3/3/25
• DoorDash order
Cheesesteak and Turkey Provolone were fantastic and fresh! the Fresh-Cut Fries were good but cold and I heated them too long in the air fryer. But I am a huge fan of the white bread and we've been looking for a new sub place since subway isn't cutting it. Will be ordering again!!
Jessica W
2 contributions
Liked
• 17/8/25
• DoorDash order
We got the Cheesesteak and Grilled Club both with customizations. They were exactly how we ordered them. It was probably the best sub sandwich I've had in a long time. We got the Large portion of both sandwiches. We ordered a medium Fresh-Cut Fries to share.They weren't the greatest. Limp and soggy but I threw them in my air fryer for a cpl mins and they were good to eat. I would recommend and order again.
S
SARAH D
5 contributions
Loved
• 20/10/23
• DoorDash order
I'm NEVER disappointed, and they are meticulous with their orders. Everything ALWAYS comes the way I ask. My chew steak and fries are sooo delicious, highly satisfied!
Juan M
1 contributions
Loved
• 28/2/25
• DoorDash order
I love this place, make the best Subs known to man, I never get disappointed,, always fresh and delicious.. Penn Station #1 in my book.
