Hands down, the NACHO AVERAGE PIZZA ***LIMITED TIME*** is the best pizza in Billings. Worth the price and absolutely delicious. The pizza was fluffy where it's supposed to be fluffy, cheesy where it was supposed to be cheesy, and crunchy where it's supposed to be crunchy. 10/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Any way you rate them, they're the best. Highly recommend 👌 ❤️🤤
E
Erik H
1 contributions
Loved
• 21/10/25
• DoorDash order
The SICILIAN PEPPERONI ROLLS™ are a good value and very tasty. The BONELESS CHICKEN WINGS SHORT was smaller than I expected for the price but tasted good. Order was ready for pickup when I expected it to be. Staff are super friendly.
D
Dakota P
2 contributions
Loved
• 13/5/26
• DoorDash review
So Old Chicago= AMAZING. I ordered 3 pizzas, pep rolls, fried pickles, cheese sticks, and firecracker shrimp. All of it was AMAZING and tasted super fresh. Best pizza in billings in my opinion. Even better than pie guys, and I work at pie guys! The staff was friendly. Mattea, the host, went above and beyond to make me happy and have a good time while I waited like 3 mins for my food. (I arrived early) the staff was doin their job but kept coming up to me to ask if I've been helped and they were VERY friendly and cracked a few jokes. The manager, Alex, was super friendly and very polite. I would HIGLY recommend this establishment for anyone who likes good food and service. Will for sure be coming back!
S
Shelly P
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/2/26
• DoorDash order
We were really disappointed with our food, which surprised us because we love Old Chicago.
We ordered a pizza with extra green olives and less cheese. I swear they purposely did the opposite of that. There were maybe 6 olives total on the large pizza. I believe paid over three dollars to get extra. And there was more cheese on the pizza than we normally get when ordering this pizza.
The fried pickles were undercooked and it was our first time not finishing fried pickles from anywhere.
The jalapeno pretzel and wings were good. And the door dasher did great.
R
Robert J
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 23/8/25
• DoorDash order
I think they had someone new working in the kitchen becase the BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLLS were awful. Oily, almost empty, no onion or garnish and thrown in a pizza box to roll around. Usually they are delicious, full of meat and cheese, garnished, and well packaged in a plastic tray. The extra cups of ranch we purchased were also off. They were like water with no taste. The ADDITIONAL SAUCES are cheap but still disappointing.
