Ice cream was good as always, but they didn't pack the cones well and they all came cracked.
M
Mark & Melinda C
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/7/25
• DoorDash order
Ummm duh... this is what you would call a city staple; in this case that city would be Cincinnati so it's a Cincinnati staple and it lives up to the hype. I'm not a born and raised native, I've literally lived in the south, the north, the midwest, both coasts . I don't consider that a weakness while writing this review but rather, a strength. The only thing stopping it from being a super power would be if I had forays in the international space. Does Epcot centers world stage count though? If so, I'm gettin' a cape y'all 🤣
Let's get down to business though right? They have classic favorites that are always on the menu while also having seasonal favorites as well as brand new additions that never disappoint. Greater's ice cream has a taste that can only be rivaled by maybe one or two other ice cream parlors but they are still my #1, lil shout out to Jeni's y'all, hailing from the mothership city north of us in Columbus, definitely close 2nd place, but, again, let's get back to Graeter's!! They are generous with their portions, while still being fair when it comes to price, always fresh like it was made the same day. I would absolutely order again. This is not my first rodeo with them and it won't be my last! Now it's time to get back to my Midnight Snack !
A
Amber C
Local Expert • 49 contributions
Loved
• 2/11/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was correct. The taste is amazing. The portion size is exactly what I ordered. I will order again.
B
Brennan W
5 contributions
Loved
• 27/1/23
• DoorDash order
The Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip Pint was a good move. It was delivered cold just as it should've been!!
S
Shana B
1 contributions
Loved
• 22/9/21
• DoorDash order
Sent a pint of ice cream to my precious mother-in-law. The perfect recipe for her rehabilitation!
Thank you for making her day! 
