Honestly, this is the best 18" Cheese Pizza I've had since relocating to Polk County last summer. No frills, no nonsense, no trying to be something it's not; just a GOOD classic NY Style pie. The cheese, the crust, the sauce... bravo, Cicalas.
As for the 10 Wings the flavor was great. They were a *touch* overcooked for my taste, but I'd rather that to ab undercooked wing ANY day. No points lost at all.
I will definitely be ordering again.
Tracy B
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 25/7/25
• DoorDash review
Absolutely amazing food here! My slice of cheese pizza was bigger than my head which was great! The only thing I was disappointed with was I never got any napkins, plates, utensils for salad, and no straw for my drink!
T
Tanya W
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 7/12/25
• DoorDash order
18" Cheese Pizza is always fresh and good. Never have any complaints. We tried the 18" Spicy Italian Pizza for the first time. It was different but good.
I personally didn't like the Broccoli Penne Dinner one option was to add grilled chicken but the texture of the chicken seemed like it was grilled can chicken. I also wasn't a fan of the fried croutons. Ther portion was a good size though, even though I won't order that meal again.
C
Cambron C
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/6/26
• DoorDash order
Generally Cicalas has been on point. However the last two times I've been disappointed. Last time, I went to pick my pizza up, they had no record of it and I received confirmation by email. This time the pizza was crammed into a box that was too small.
L
Lisa F
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/5/26
• DoorDash order
My 14" Cheese Pizza that I added additional toppings to were all missing, the Fried Calamari was very fishy tasting and the breading was different colors like some had been refried. I have never had any issues previously, hoping this was just a bad night.
