Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria is my go-to pizza spot in Idaho Falls! Every order arrives hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The crust has that perfect New York-style bite—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside and the toppings are always generous and fresh. You can tell they take pride in every pizza they make. The quality never disappoints. If you’re looking for authentic New York-style pizza in East Idaho, this is the place. Outstanding food, excellent consistency, and absolutely worth every penny.
J
Jason B
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 8/8/26
• DoorDash order
Ordered the Brooklyn pepperoni and cheese sticks again and Lucy’s delivered once more. The pizza crust is always perfect crispy on the edges, soft in the middle and the pepperoni is generous and flavorful. Cheese sticks came out hot, gooey, and covered in that garlic butter just the way they should.
Everything was packed well and still piping hot when it arrived. This place is so consistent it’s almost unfair. Every single order hits the same high level. Easily the best pizza in Idaho Falls.
A
Aimee T
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/3/25
• DoorDash review
One calzone was burnt and stuck to the box, with the ends of the tomato left and not cut. Second calzone was gooey and very thin. First time ordering here, very disappointed. $30 in the trash.
M
Mel N
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/1/26
• DoorDash order
I love Lucy's! It has never disappointed. I recently discovered that they are awesome at hot wings! Unfortunately, today my order of 10 wings, included one meaty leg, 8 wings and literally a lost random wing; fried with no meat. Total bummer!!!
A
Alicia A
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Liked
• 21/12/25
• DoorDash order
I feel like my calzone would have been a lot better without the pineapple, sadly. it was bitter and not sweet at all. I wasn't too impressed with the cannolis. The filling was very thick and not light and fluffy like I expected and the shell was quite thick and.
