Midnite Slice is located in the original post office in historic old Seabrook.
The structure is nearly a century old and has gorgeous wood walls and floors.
We LOVED everything! The pizza rolls are "outta this world"!!! The "Scoop Fries" are unlike anything we've ever had and are delicious! My hubby loved his Stromboli and the wings can fly themselves to Mars and back! Oh the ranch is Devine and the marina is so fresh it makes you blush! Loved it all!
C
Cassandra O
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
Didn't like
• 19/6/25
• DoorDash order
Im disappointed in the food tonight. Usually they are good. Pizza is super chewy and has a plasticity taste to it, d ough was burnt. Brownie girl was a good portion for 2 people.
E
Evan F
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/11/23
• DoorDash order
This is my first bad review of this place because it is my absolute favorite. The pizza got in late so I had to wait a little which I don't mind, but when I got home I realized I was given a medium cheese pizza when I actually ordered an extra large pizza because it was for two people. The cost and size is a considerable difference so I was pretty bummed out about not getting what ordered.
A
Andrea R
14 contributions
Loved
• 31/8/25
• DoorDash order
The last couple of times my pizza was lopsided and uneven. My crust was not crispy and buttery like previous times. Whoever made it today saw my note because my pizza was perfect! Each slice is thin, crispy, and buttery!!!! I've been sick for the last week so I was really looking forward to biting into this now that my tastebuds have returned. Keep up the good work guys!!!
A
Alexandra D
Emerging Expert • 34 contributions
Liked
• 3/1/26
• DoorDash order
I had some of my roomie's pizza rolls and the cheesy bread. The cheesy bread was ok, but those pizza rolls were super good!
If you don't like bluebell icecream, just get the dirty girl instead of the Nasty Girl Brownie. I can't eat carageenan without getting sick, so I didn't end up eating the icecream. The brownie to icecream ration was off, too. A huge honkin slab like that thang needs two scoops total. I couldn't eat it in once sitting, even without the icecream!
I'm gonna presume the Out to Dry Salad is the same quality since I'm saving it for tomorrow lol.
Roomie said the pizza was crispy so that gets my vote, good stuff!
All in all a solid experience, great job!
