Our philosophy. Old-fashioned Kettle Boyle Baked to perfection It's not really a secret that the natives of Long Island are obsessed with bagels. This is the type of competitive environment in which t…
The Novalicious was amazing this time around. Good amount of Lox and everything else was perfect. I think I've found my new favorite sandwich from here.
K
K S
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/11/23
• DoorDash order
There were only four triangles of French toast when the photo showed six. There were no strawberries. It is very bland and dry without much egg on some pieces. Not worth that price at all. There was no syrup or butter. The salt and pepper I asked for were in the French toast container but were too soggy from condensation and spilled hot sauce to open and use. There was no silverware though I requested it specifically. The bagel was nice enough but overall not a good experience and would not order again.
D
Donny G
3 contributions
Liked
• 22/12/25
• DoorDash order
Great sandwich every time my bagel was a little burnt but that's okay. But if you guys are reading this can you's please seal or staple the bag gives me a little assurance that the food was in tampered with on the  delivery, 
J
Jay F
Emerging Expert • 93 contributions
Loved
• 25/8/23
• DoorDash order
The best place for cream cheese of any flavor. The best bagels. The best macaroni salad. Been going here for years and never fails.
M
Marlene P
Local Expert • 34 contributions
Liked
• 2/12/23
• DoorDash review
Literally the only place in town for a real legitimate bagel when it's after hours. When one of those sad diner bagels just won't do, it's great to know there's Long Island Bagel cafe. Unfortunately, the chopped 'salad bar' salad we also ordered was not good. My husband took a bite, said it was terrible and just threw it out. That's pretty bad.
