ATHENA
In Greek mythology, Athena was the goddess of war and wisdom. According to one legend, she was born fully grown and the Gods' king. Athena symbolized the intellectual side of warfare. The Parth…
I got the Athena's, the portion was huge, 4 meals out of it! The salad was nice and fresh and a huge piece of garlic bread. Cheesecake was cheesecake, but still good. I would definitely order from here again. Money well spent!
J
Jen T
1 contributions
Loved
• 12/10/25
• DoorDash order
We've been going to Athena's for years! I'm an NYC native and pizza snob... Plus I have Celiac. Their pizza isn't technically Celiac-safe because it is made in a shared oven, but their GF crusts are in their own pans, and they are FABULOUS! For me personally it's well worth the activated charcoal to ward off any reaction to cross-contamination. Their regular pizza is also awesome (from what I remember prior to being diagnosed). They are a small, family-owned restaurant that takes pride in being respectful to their customers and making quality food. I don't think they have ever once gotten our order wrong in the 10+ years we've been going here. It's exciting to be able to get them delivered outside of Amherst!
F
Fredrika W
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/3/26
• DoorDash order
The Lasagna was at least 2/3 just red sauce, and maybe 1/3 was actual lasagna. Literally a huge amount of meat marinara, a little sheet of pasta folded in the middle, sprinkled with mozz and then covered in more sauce. I'm honestly not sure if there was any ricotta in it. The packaging weighed well over a pound, so basically I spent $27 all told on a giant serving of tomato sauce priced at $20, with a side salad and a piece of bread.
K
Kayte L
Emerging Expert • 26 contributions
Loved
• 13/6/25
• DoorDash order
This is my favorite restaurant in the area. The sandwiches on the pita are the best subs I've ever had, pizza is delicious, I love the crust and the crispy crunchy little wings!
M
Mari S
3 contributions
Liked
• 26/8/25
• DoorDash order
Food was very tasty but the sizes of the pizzas did not match our expectations. We got a large and a small, but the sizes seemed more like medium and personal. So I recommend customers "size up" if they need the specific sizes to feed a group. That said, flavors were great.
