hard to top this place for sandwichs. got the special pastrami/cornbeef swiss sub. i thought it was a sandwich but huge amount of meat and melt in your mouth. had them add saurkraut even though i didn't know was gonna be cold. delicious. also, got a knish for the first time. will definitely order again. love this place
K
Kate D
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 20/1/26
• DoorDash order
The best subs in town! I always get a ton of pickles 🥒🥒 BP special and Chicken Salad - Whole Sub delicious and so filling. I wasn't sure what the special was but we ordered it anyway, and it ended up being chicken and bicuits! 🥰 We knew we would like whatever they had.
C
Cheryl O
7 contributions
Loved
• 7/4/25
• DoorDash order
Italian - Whole SubDirty Chips Maui Onion (2 oz Bags)Antipasto
Seems to be the best Doordash value. Brooklyn Pickle never disappoints. Sub was fat with meat and cheese. Salad was huge and fresh!
F
Food Critic M
Local Expert • 50 contributions
Liked
• 4/1/26
• DoorDash order
I just want to say 5 out 5 the staff is amazing they follow my request and my Brooklyn Pickle Special - Whole was so delicious I forgot to take a pic but I remembered to leave a review.simply fantastic it was meaty fresh and if you looking for a great sandwich spot go here trust me they will not disappoint, super friendly I even called to ask questions person on the phone was fantastic n very kind overall great service and great food
F
Food Critic M
Local Expert • 50 contributions
Liked
• 20/2/26
• DoorDash order
I absolutely love Brooklyn pickle they always follow instructions I leave and makes my food with care and love even with my small details. The sandwiches are dope and ingredients taste fresh Simply amazing
