Buttermilk Sky Pie
4.8(200+)•
DashPass•
Bakery•
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(200+)•
$$•Bakery
Cecily and JP are the proud owners of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Colleyville, continuing the traditions that have made this location a local favorite since 2016. What started as a simple dessert stop …
Full Menu
10:00 am–6:30 pmFeatured Items
USD 0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Stack of 4 Mini-Pies
USD 28.60
9" Chocolate Cream
USD 45.50
9" I 40
USD 45.50
9" Key Lime
USD 45.50
9" Pecan
USD 45.50
9" Coconut Cream
USD 45.50
Reviews200+ ratings • 9 public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
E
E C T
12 contributionsLoved
• 2/2/25Key lime was delicious! All were beautiful. Will enjoy the others soon. Love the fact we can order the small Set of 4 Mini Pies with Twine Bow & Gift Tag Enjoy variety of pies.
A
Anne T
7 contributionsLoved
• 16/4/26Incredible pies. Hands down the best cream pies ever bought. The apple and pecan pies were very good but the others were 10/10!
A
Amber S
8 contributionsDidn't like
• 8/6/25Peanut Butter pie was not set. Apple was very dry and not pie like at all. It lost consistency with the filling. It seems as if it had flour added to it? Great disservice to an otherwise tasty flavor combo. Buttermilk pie. Same thing. Filling is too thick. even a buttermilk pie has a delicate, almost creme brulee consistency.
C
Cassie T
1 contributionsLoved
• 17/3/22the Mini Pies are positively delicious (the I40, Coconut creme, chocolate cream, and chocolate chip cookie all perfection), and the vanilla cookies are absolutely worth it!
M
Melissa M
5 contributionsDidn't like
• 4/1/24Why did my pies look so sad? Disappointed they were so concave. Why skimp on the filling? Meh. Not worth the price. Not eve close.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store