The Jersey Devil is actually the perfect sandwich. The oil on it gives a nice kick, cutlet and eggplant are perfectly fried, and the mozzarella is fresh. It's my favorite sandwich. The Beef vegetable with Pastina is also amazing. The beef is so tender and the soup is so flavorful. The veggies are cooked thoroughly and taste great.
F
Francis D
Emerging Expert • 39 contributions
Loved
• 8/3/26
• DoorDash order
Probably the best tasting g steak I've had in a while. Shaved Ribeye Steak sandwich was tender and flavorful. Also plentiful. The Sarcone roll was a winner too. French Fries were seasoned beautifully. Will surely order again.
M
Michael E
4 contributions
Loved
• 20/9/25
• DoorDash order
⭐ Cafe Merlino Review ⭐
Wanted a few apps while I watched the Mets game so I tried out Cafe Merlino recently and the food was solid all around. I ordered the arancini balls, onion rings, and the truffle wings.
The arancini balls were a standout — crispy on the outside, creamy inside, and had a nice touch of truffle flavor that really came through.
The onion rings were classic, crunchy, and satisfying. I didn't receive the pedals as advertised I got the regular onion rings but still solid
The truffle wings didn’t carry as much of that truffle flavor I was hoping for, but they were still delicious in their own right.
Only knock? The sauce containers. A couple came barely 1/3 full — sauce us up next time, LOL.
Overall, everything tasted great and came together as a satisfying meal. I’m a big truffle fan, so I especially appreciated that note in the arancini. I’d definitely order from here again.
Final score: 8.3/10.
M
Megan M
1 contributions
Loved
• 29/3/26
• DoorDash review
The absolute best there is, a local gem for sure. Don't pass on the chicken pastina soup, if you come from an Italian household eating this is like the equivalent feeling of coming home. The portions are filling, always fresh, you will be craving it time and time again. All I ask is that you PLEASE ADD THE BELLA TO DOORDASH, it is my favorite and sometimes I just can't get to the shop. Appreciate you for amazing food, quality and service every time.
S
Sophia M
1 contributions
Loved
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
The caesar salad with diced chicken cutlet is one of the best around and I have tried plenty. The portion size is enough to fill you all day and the flavor doesn't miss. Definitely give it a try!
