Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant

4.7

(530+ ratings)|

Pizza, Italian|$$

At Caragiulos, the food speaks for itself. Using the finest ingredients, Caragiulos has served easy- going, inventive Italian-American comfort food since 1989. The bread is baked on the premises each …

Ratings & Reviews

4.7

530+ ratings

USD 0.00

delivery fee, first order

to see delivery time

The hours this store accepts DoorDash orders

4:30 pm–8:40 pm

4:30 pm–9:40 pm

(Today)

4:30 pm–8:40 pm

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Popular Items

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Appetizers

Soups / Salads

Dinner Pasta

Pizza

Entrees

Sides

Desserts

Soft Drinks

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Ratings & Reviews

4.7

530+ ratings, 16 public reviews

Erin J

• 20/10/21

• DoorDash Review

Everything I have tried from the fish to the pasta has been amazing. I love the beet salad!

Andrea J

• 13/11/22

• DoorDash Order

ZEPPOLI & GELATO are packaged together. Gelato was melted and Zeppoli soggy with condensation. Frozen and hot items shouldn't be in the same container. Meatballs had the taste and texture of meatloaf and the sausage was burnt. Huge disappointment. $25 a plate for the trash.

Scott J

• 3/1/22

• DoorDash Order

The eggplant was very chewy, little sauce on the pasta , was trying something different but should have stayed with better dishes that I've had before (tortoloni, bring back the old recipe)! Soup was OK, should have larger pasta and more spinach. Delivery was A+.

Helpful (1)

Sarah C

• 1/1/22

• DoorDash Order

Instead of the ribbon noodles, I got lasagne noodles in a heap and it was almost impossible to eat. The sauce tasted like ketchup!!! This was supposed to be a splurge. I went to sleep hungry. What a joke and waste of food.

Rost K

• 22/3/23

• DoorDash Review

Probably the best Italian rest in Sarasota.

Travis C

• 15/3/23

• DoorDash Order

food was eh at best for the price we paid expected authentic Italian not microwaved sauce and box noodles

Caragiulos Italian American Restaurant

Most Liked Items From The Menu

PASTA MIA

SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS

CHIARA'S TIRAMISU

Popular Items

PASTA MIA

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER

ADDITIONAL SIDE OF FOCACCIA BREAD

TORTELLONI TARTUFO

CHIARA'S TIRAMISU

WEDDING SOUP

CHEESE PIZZA

RAVIOLI alla VODKA

SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS

SMALL HOUSE SALAD

Appetizers

FRIED CALAMARI

ROMAN ARTICHOKES

MEATBALLS AL FORNO

CAPRESE BOARD

SALUMI e FORMAGGI BOARD

MUSSELS CALABRESE

AVOCADO BRUSCHETTA

VEGETARIANO BOARD

CHICKEN LIVER PATE

CALAMARI FRITTO MISTO

CAULIFLOWER MAC & CHEESE

Soups / Salads

SMALL CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

LARGE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

SMALL HOUSE SALAD

LARGE CHOPPED 1989 SALAD

WEDDING SOUP

LARGE SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD

SMALL SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD

SMALL CHOPPED 1989 SALAD

LARGE HOUSE SALAD

LARGE ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD

SMALL ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD

Dinner Pasta

PASTA MIA

RAVIOLI alla VODKA

RIGATONI & SHORT RIB RAGU

SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS

ANGEL HAIR ARRABIATA

RIGATONI PASOLINI

LASAGNA al FORNO

TORTELLONI TARTUFO

SPAGHETTI & CEDAR KEY CLAMS

SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE + MEATBALL

SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE

Pizza

'PIZZA MIA'

CHEESE PIZZA

MARGHERITA

WILD MUSHROOM & FONTINA

PEAR & GORGONZOLA

CALZONE

DAVINCI

BIANCA ROSSA

AGRO DOLCE

FIVE LILY

'JOE da GREEK'

Entrees

CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER

CHICKEN PICATTA

LOCAL GROUPER

CHICKEN MARSALA

BALSAMIC SKIRT STEAK

EGGPLANT al FORNO

VEAL PARMIGIANA

PICATTA STYLE VEAL

VEAL MARSALA

Sides

SIDE PASTA

SIDE 2 MEATBALLS

CACIO e PEPE CORN RISOTTO

ADDITIONAL SIDE OF FOCACCIA BREAD

ARANCINI VERDE