There’s a lot of good pizza in New York City. Not all rise to the level of greatness, but the pies at Emmy Squared do. Part of the beloved Pizza Loves Emily mini-chain, Emmy Squared, serves (yes) squa…
This place is always a winner! The pizza is like nothing else and the burgers are incredible. They advertise that the burgers have been voted number one in several places and I can see why! I cant say enough good things about them.
A
Amanda C
2 contributions
Loved
• 26/9/25
• DoorDash order
I have Celiac's and had messed up the DoorDash order for my salad, called the store and they took care of me. So grateful and so excited to find a new place for a treat (which isn't easy with Celiac's but there are gems out there like Emmy Squared). The gluten free pizza crust is stellar!! Highly recommend!
E
Ella D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 22/3/25
• DoorDash review
The pizza was a let down for sure. Ceasar salad was a waste of money, but we paid $13.50 for it. Despite the advertisement, it was only thick white parts of ice burg lettuce and maybe one shake of grocery store parmesan. DONT order it. We also ordered the margherita and it was advertised to have burrata on every piece. We received maybe 1/4 of a piece of burrata for the whole pizza. The pizza was fine (which is why I gave it two stars), but if you're going to spend $25 on a pizza, do it somewhere else that makes it worth it. Will never order again.
E
Elizabeth R
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 27/10/26
• DoorDash order
2 big fingernail sized chunks of bone in the shaved sirloin pizza I got - how do you miss that? the Angel Pizza was ok but left a coat of unpleasant grease taste and the sauces on top were blobbed on randomly so some pieces had none. the Le Big Matt (Single or Double)was awful too- incredibly dry charred burger. I honestly have no idea why this place has such great reviews.
J
Jennifer H
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 24/3/25
• DoorDash order
sauce was way too sweet, pizza was tiny for the price, fake honey flavor. should have gone with a frozen pizza over this.... very disappointed.
