I ordered about 30 min before closing (I didn’t realize how late it was), & when I called the store to check if they could fulfill it, the staff was incredibly polite, patient, and upfront. They explained the timing amd situation without any attitude, and told me they’d hang tight as long as possible in case a Dasher picked my order. That level of kindness and respect near closing...is rare and truly appreciated. (Maybe it's because when I was very young a long time ago I was once a line cook)
anywho, a Dasher accepted the order quickly, and when it arrived to sweetwater, I was so please that I felt like I needed to make a review. The pizza was still hot, the crust golden brown, the cheese perfectly gooey and stretchy, and every bite hit all the right flavor notes. The slightly sweet dough, rich sauce, and balanced saltiness created an absolutely delicious harmony. Papa John’s garlic butter is next level. l recommend Spicy Garlic Sauce 5 out of five ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐,..⭐
N
Nick K
3 contributions
Loved
• 16/5/25
• DoorDash review
I ordered about 30 min before closing (I didn't realize how late it was), & when I called the store to check if they could fulfill it, the staff was incredibly polite, patient, and upfront. They explained the timing amd situation without any attitude, and told me they'd hang tight as long as possible in case a Dasher picked my order. That level of kindness and respect near closing...is rare and truly appreciated. (Maybe it's because when I was very young a long time ago I was once a line cook)
anywho, a Dasher accepted the order quickly, and when it arrived to sweetwater, I was so please that I felt like I needed to make a review. The pizza was still hot, the crust golden brown, the cheese perfectly gooey and stretchy, and every bite hit all the right flavor notes. The slightly sweet dough, rich sauce, and balanced saltiness created an absolutely delicious harmony. Papa John's garlic butter is next level. I recommend Spicy Garlic Sauce 5 out of five ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐,..⭐
D
Diane C
12 contributions
Loved
• 7/11/26
• DoorDash order
I absolutely LOVE papa John's I recommend any of there pizzas!!! Hands down best pizza in town, if I could afford I definitely have this a couple times a week
H
Hope B
4 contributions
Loved
• 8/8/26
• DoorDash order
I Loved The Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza and my kiddo loved her Cheesesticks. The Only Issue Was The Wait On My Order.
L
Linda W
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 19/9/26
• DoorDash order
Crust was too doughy. Couldn't taste the pepperoni. Not enough sausage. The mushrooms were good. Bring back the spinach Alfredo.