The Pilgrim Diner located in Cedar Grove originally opened its doors in 1965 and has recently gone through a complete renovation. You can now enjoy our updated menu that includes breakfast (available …
Mozzarella Sticks These are my favorite mozzarella sticks out of all the local places that sell them. They are more battered rather than breaded. Sometimes we make the decision to get from Pilgrim entirely based on getting the Mozzarella Sticks.
K
Kathleen D
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Loved
• 18/5/26
• DoorDash order
I can always count on Pilgrim Diner for a delicious order. They follow my instructions for specific requests. I usually order eggs and they are never overcooked or brown--neither are the scrambled eggs/omelettes undercooked and runny. They are equally meticulous about their home fries with onions. The potatoes are cooked through to a golden brown and the onions are always starting to nicely carmelize. You know they care about what they are doing when one of the simplest items on the menu is prepared so well. Thanks to everyone there!
E
Elizabeth S
1 contributions
Liked
• 10/2/26
• DoorDash order
My barbecued rib dinner was absolutely amazing! I know a lot of people would say you're crazy for ordering that from a diner, but I have to tell you the ribs were absolutely fall off the bone. The mashed potatoes were delicious delicious the fresh vegetables were great. The Greek salad was amazing. Pilgrim diner never disappoints.
K
Kathleen D
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
Loved
• 16/7/25
• DoorDash order
Great omelette---cooked just right.
I ordered the home fries with onions and the onions were beautifully browned and tasty!
This I why I ordered so regularly from them.
C
Cathy B
7 contributions
Loved
• 2/8/25
• DoorDash order
Perfectly cooked hamburger with fresh crisp lettuce, tomato and red onion. Plenty of delicious fries.
