Mario and Angelina Mastroianni nurtured a love of all things Italian in their sons: the country, the people, the customs, and the cuisine. Mario, a shoemaker by trade, knew the value of great material…
This might be our new go to pizza place! wings were crispy and delicious, pizza was packed with flavor and the garlic bread was exactly what you wanted it to be: smothered im cheese, fresh garlic and butter.
T
Tamara M
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Loved
• 1/3/26
• DoorDash order
I have been ordering from P Jay's for nearly 20 years and throughout this time, their food has always been fresh, delicious and affordable. Their portion sizes have always been consistent also. I love that they have such an awesome variety of items to choose from on their menu and are always running some sort of a special or a coupon promotion. I have never had any issues with missing items and their service is always phenomenal. Delivery is always fast and their drivers are very friendly, even when I order directly through their app. I will definitely continue to order from them and recommend them to all my friends and family.
M
Melissa K
Local Expert • 122 contributions
Liked
• 12/1/25
• DoorDash order
My order was a little uneven this time. The Chocolate Chip Cookie Pizza was a little well done in spots. The Deluxe had a bit of a strange taste. However the Boneless Wings were large and tasty and the Sausage Sub had a delicious sauce and cheese. I have ordered from here before and am usually really pleased. Any place can have an off night so I would still recommend give this place a try.
J
Jason N
Local Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 10/3/25
• DoorDash order
The Jumbo 16" 12 cut pizza was very good! Arrived very hot and delicious. If you love bacon on your pizza, there's is the best! It is thin, crispy, delicious and they put a ton of it all over the pizza. Overall I really enjoyedthis pizza and would recommend it to anyone.
H
Holly W
2 contributions
Loved
• 12/8/24
• DoorDash order
Pjay's is by far one of the best pizza places in Parma. I tend to avoid chain pizza and support local. Pjay's pizza is always fabulous. Great sauce, perfect ratio of toppings and cheese, phenomenal crust that needs no additions. The wings are great as well. Have and always will highly recommend!
