Usually this place is very good but today my BE on roll came with incredibly thick slices of tomato and very little bacon on white toast. The diner called to explain they only had one roll to use for the other sandwich, but I hung up believing it was a SPAM call. My wife stated the roll for her sandwich came with seeds, and tasted like it was a day old. We were a little disappointed.
R
Randy F
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/11/22
• DoorDash review
This order was delivered fine from Door Dash, however the order itself was not. The hamburger which was ordered medium was received beyond well done and very very dry. The Reuben, $16.85 was more like a sauerkraut sandwich, with no thousand island dressing and very few slices of corned beef. The pickles placed in a waxed paper bag which soaked through caused everything to be wet with pickle juice and everything needed to be wiped down. A two piece order costing over $41 and received in such a condition is unacceptable from the Putnam diner. Please consider this when placing your order.
R
Randy F
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/11/22
• DoorDash order
Where do I start. New place added so we tried it but there won't be another order. Ordered medium hamburger came beyond well done, very dry. The Reuben (14.65) was not a Reuben it was a sauerkraut sandwich. A few slices of corned beef, no thousand island dressing. Two pickles in a waxed paper bag, bag was soaked and rip had to wipe down everything.
Want a burger and a Reuben order from Kelly's pub.
C
Claire H
1 contributions
Loved
• 8/11/25
• DoorDash order
this is the second time i ordered this. the corned beef is AMAZING and fresh and they give you a lot. they forgot to add the cheese and lettuce this time but i would still get it again
