Friendships are formed and memories are made at Windsor Mill Tavern. The Windsor Mill's historic components are preserved while modern upgrades are made to the garden-level basement, which includes ce…
i fancy myself something of a burger connoisseur. This was, by FAR, the BEST Burger I have had in over 20 years. I wish I could have eaten 3 more. Absolutely everything a Burger should be; don't even get me started on the French Fries. 20/10.
M
Maria T
14 contributions
Loved
• 22/4/26
• DoorDash order
The cuisine was exceptional, with the Crispy Chicken Sandwich and the Smoke Tri Tip Sandwich both receiving high praise. The Cheese Curds were also excellent. While we typically prefer dining on-site, the quality of the meals was nearly comparable to an in-person experience at the Windsor Mill.
We did utilize an air fryer to enhance the crispness of the fries.
M
Michael D
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 13/9/25
• DoorDash order
1/2 Chicken Tenders: Fries missing and tenders burnt. So after tax and tip, that's about $20 for three little tenders. We scraped the burned breading off and ate the overcooked chicken anyway. The chicken otherwise seemed of high quality, all white strips.
Burger: Likely would have been much better eaten there. The bottom bun was totally sopping wet and inedible. The beef patty was well cooked (medium well) but tasted unseasoned.
Green beans: Slightly under, but otherwise the best part of the meal. A lot of garlic and tasty.
Smoked wings: Bourbon Glaze was very blackened and tasted (smelled) oddly of burnt soy sauce -- probably just carbonized sugar from the glaze.
Some of these issues may have been due to ordering delivery on a busy Friday evening, but it's hard to overlook everything.
J
Janel S
10 contributions
Loved
• 14/3/26
• DoorDash order
I have ordered this so many times and the key is when the sun-dried tomatoes are just a tad crispy. It is amazing! Love this dish so so much. I would order it, well I already have. Going on six times now! I ordered it all the time because it's fresh. The proportion is very nice.. one time it could've been a little longer cooked. It wasn't undercooked. It just didn't have the crispy sun-dried tomatoes.
S
Sarah W
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Liked
• 11/5/25
• DoorDash order
The Fig & Apple Salad Full was a sad excuse for a salad. The flavor was fine, but not worth the price. The sweet potato fries had no taste. The 1/2 Chicken Tenders and Bavarian Pretzel were good. The Housemade Bread Pudding came as 3 cold pieces with a sauce on the side. I guess it's a do it yourself bread pudding.
