I just found my forever pizza place! The slices are HUGE and I think I just teleported to NYC pizza! Amazing!
M
Melissa N
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
Pizza looks worse than a microwave grocery store pizza. Teeny tiny cubes of what is supposed to be ham. Everything slid completely to the side. And the parts that still have toppings resemble elementary school food. I'm not even eating the $30 pizza and want my money back.
B
Brittany H
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 22/2/26
• DoorDash order
Their pizzas are amazing. The mushroom truffle cauliflower pizza is really great. The portion sizes are good, and the price for cauliflower pizza is excellent. Every ingredient seems fresh, and I will definitely order from Wiseguy again. I just moved here from California, and I don't understand why nobody has barbecue chicken pizza, though. I bet this place could make an amazing bbq pizza. Please let people on the East Coast know the tastiness of barbecue chicken pizza! :)
E
Eric W
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 14/9/22
• DoorDash order
Order 18" Whitestone pizza and added bacon and onions - for a $33+ pizza, the over all taste was bland and disappointing. Additionally, neither of the added items were visible nor could be tasted. I had high hopes for the NYC style crust but it was dry and also lacked flavor.
S
Sachi C
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 28/8/25
• DoorDash order
Love the Backyard Slice and Paneer Tikka Slice. Good portion and always comes fresh. Would order again 100%.
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Specials
18 Inch Whole Pizzas
9 Inch Whole Pizzas
Cauliflower Pies
NOTE: While this gluten-free, it is prepared in a common kitchen with risk of gluten exposure - This is not for individuals with Celiac Disease.
Vegan Pizzas
Square Pizzas
30 minutes baking time. Cooked Well Done.
By The Slice
Slices are cut from our whole pies - and at 18" Big Apple Size, they're 65% bigger than the typical average-sized pizza!
*Please note, there are NO modifications or additions available for slices. All come as described.
