New York Pizza
4.5(2k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(2k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
The New York Pizza is still one of Tustin's most popular restaurants. Give them a go and see why they're so popular.
Try some of Tustin's best cuisine for a full taste of the city. Discover why these…
Full Menu
10:30 a.m. - 8:40 p.m.Featured Items
US$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing and fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Pizza (Extra Large)
US$18.99
•90% (70)
#3 Most liked
Pizza (Large)
US$14.99
•90% (170)
#1 Most liked
Pizza (Medium)
US$11.99
•92% (151)
#2 Most liked
Pizza (King Kong)
US$27.99
•91% (23)
Supreme
US$19.50
•89% (39)
Meat Lovers
US$17.99
•94% (51)
Reviews2k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
D
Dylan D
Emerging Expert • 28 contributionsLoved
• 26-08-25The Pizza (King Kong) is undefeated. Perfectly balanced za. The cheese to topping ratio is radicle. The dough holds firm enough to almost pass the flop test even though the slice is like a foot long. The red sauce takes you to flavor town. Best za around! NIIIIII!!!!!!!!
V
Valentina T
3 contributionsLiked
• 25-03-20So good! 10x better than any fast food pizza chain. They did kind of skimp out on the added chicken for our pepperoni pizza but I loved the Hawaiian pizza. Super crunchy, great ingredients! Definitely recommend.
D
Dylan D
Emerging Expert • 28 contributionsDidn't like
• 26-10-05Way too light on the cheese and the sauce. Toppings were spread very thin as well. Flavors good, but it's very bare. Massive pizza though and cooked perfectly. But pretty much just bread
A
Alison D
Local Expert • 28 contributionsLoved
• 22-12-11You can't beat their prices! I said a whole crew of men for 25 bucks! And the pizza… It's really good!! I'm trying a new pizza place I always just get pepperoni. If the pepperoni is delicious, then you know everything else is going to be good! The dough is fantastic. The crust is chewy. On my second and third orders I tried the meat lovers and the supreme. Everyone was happy! Fresh. Tasty. Delicious.
S
Sarah C
Emerging Expert • 7 contributionsLoved
• 25-06-20Wow! This is AMAZING pizza!
I absolutely LOVE pizza and it HAS to be done a certain way--the RIGHT way. And this is it---and the prices cannot be beat. We ordered a medium NY style pepperoni pizza. We should have gotten a large (rookie mistake)---it was FABULOUS and it was GONE in 10 minutes---half of it didn't even make it out of the car! My husband also loved his chicken parm sub and it was also gone in record time. This is now our pizza place. We will be back!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Create Your Own Pizza
Choose your own sauce and toppings.
Specialty Pizza
Wings
6 or 10 pieces
Salads
Sides
Calzone
Subs
Desserts
Drinks
2 liter sodas