This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Checking if the site connection is secured...
4.7(500+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(500+)•
$•Pizzeria
Try the best pizzas in Garden City to find a new favorite.
Many pizzerias in Garden City provide more than pizza, so sample some of the city's other delicacies.
Pizza Supreme features a wide variety o…
the best damn meatballs... their unique square pizza, great other pizza styles , great baked dishes....been eating at pizza supreme for over 40 years, way back when they were in the mall ............Erik
M
Michael F
Local Expert • 40 contributions
Loved
• 24-01-10
• DoorDash order
Great pizza! Grew up on their square pies. Unique and delicious!
Slice wasnt packaged well and was ruined-couldve been dasher
C
Cristine G
4 contributions
Loved
• 24-05-08
• DoorDash order
Always perfection. Tradition continues to always have pizza supreme to celebrate my birthday! Thank you
J
Jessica L
5 contributions
Loved
• 23-07-27
• DoorDash order
Yum!! Perfectly cooked and crispy, arrived hot. Probably one of the best rice balls I've had.
T
Taffey B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 25-06-10
• DoorDash order
The pizza was not completely done. Cheese sliding all over. This is our favorite place but very disappointed this time.
