This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Checking if the site connection is secured...
4.6(1k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(1k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Thou Shalt Eat Proper Pizza Welcome to Proper Pizza and Pasta! We offer a variety of ways to dine with us, whether you are looking for delivery, dine-in, or just trying to grab a quick slice to go. Co…
20" in 20" Cheese Pizza was superb and checked all the pizza boxes as a true to form NY style pie:
•large but THIN slices
• foldable, chewy sourdough like crust with rigid crispy bottom
• cheese blend on point, sauce homemade and authentic
•perfect sauce:cheese ratio
I live about 5-6 miles away so I know it was made to order, fresh, and not ice cold by the time it arrived! Bravo!
E
Elisha L
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 25-07-10
• DoorDash order
Penne Vodkai ordered the pasta and added broccoli and mushrooms, 3 small pieces of broccoli, and basically no mushrooms for an upcharge. It is pretty ridiculous. The pizza is decent. However, I was in the mood for pasta, and this was for sure a letdown, probably wouldn't order this again.
J
Jeremy B
Local Expert • 54 contributions
Didn't like
• 25-11-17
• DoorDash order
I tried the Penne Vodka and the Fettucine Alfredo. Items came super hot and fresh and this store was 5 miles away. The vodka saauce was very bland compared to others I've had. Alfredo sauce was fine. I'm glad I bought them at their sale price but I wouldn't order from here again. Portions are bigger elsewhere on DoorDash.
C
Carlos A
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-04-29
• DoorDash order
Received a fried calzone with hardly any cheese & didnt taste very good & a piece of lasagne that measured about four fingers wide & three fingers high, very small portion & didnt taste good either, I could have made my own lasagne for what I paid here for a tiny slice. The best part of the meal was the cookie I ordered which was delicious, the mini canoli was nothing special. Overall I think it's overpriced & overrated, nothing to write home about & return.
J
Jessica J
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 26-04-28
• DoorDash order
Half of the 16" Brooklyn Square Pizza was completely burned and tasted horrible and the other half undercooked andtreating like dough, making a $35 pizza inedible($40 if you include thepepperoni we added). The XL Hot Honey Pizza was cooked well and the Garlic Knots were delicious
