This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Everything is always SO good and fresh! The Ceasar was exactly perfect when that craving hit. The Fried Ravioli is my go to comfort food, always hot & Crispy! The Slice Monthly Chef's Choice Pizza - "What's POPPIN?" was incredible! Jalapeño Popper pizza?!? SO good Crunchy, chewy, and soft crust? I don't know how it can be all those things, but it hits the spot every time!
P
Paul M
3 contributions
Liked
• 24-01-23
• DoorDash order
Fried Ravioli was okay. Would have preferred it be stuffed with meat, than just plainly stuffed with cheese. And would rather have hot marinara vs cold. But that's okay. The 2 - 1 Topping Slices were good. Your standard pepperoni pizza slice. Nice big slices, the right amount of grease, the crust was thin and and crispy how I like it. Nothing was wow about it, but it was good. I'll definitely try again in the future.
J
Jilianne W
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-12-05
• DoorDash order
10" Pizza Margherita
Pathetic. I usually get DiOrio's or even Spinelli's since my partner has a gluten allergy. 10" 2nd Street Cheese was more like 6 inches (cut into 4 tiny pieces) with barely any toppings. The crust was paper-thin and tasted freezer burned, and the sauce tasted like Ragu. Some days I don't an opportunity to eat until very late, and I'm usually stuffed after a 10" cheese from the aforementioned restaurants. This was basically just an expensive gross snack, a hot pocket would have been preferable. I'm still reeling from the over $50 everything ended up costing after delivery, tip, etc. Stick to Donisi when you're drunk and stick to the individual slices.
M
Morgan K
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 25-03-05
• DoorDash order
I'm one to leave an honest opinion, and honestly being as though this was my first time ordering here, my experience was very sour. First, I paid over $50 for this order, and all of my food came cold. The 18in 18" 2nd Street Cheese I ordered was more thin than the box it came in. It says it feeds 4-6 people, and well thats not the case. It literally feeds only two. The Meatball Sandwich looks like small sub sandwich in the picture right? At least a little 6" for $10 right? Wrong. It's literally two meatballs with half melted cheese and a thick tomato sauce that is more like paste . Also, the Traditional Mini Cannoli's I ordered, never came, soooo..yeah..wont be coming here again.
K
Kirsten W
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 23-01-25
• DoorDash order
If you're looking for NY style pizza in Louisville this is waaaay better than the "Good Guys" (aka GF) if you know what I mean. I love a nice thin crust handtossed pizza that's not crunchy like a cracker and this meets those standards! The house made sausage is my favorite topping. This has become my new fave when ordering but if you go in person you'll save $10 compared to all the Doordash fees.
