This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Crogan's is the perfection of culinary delight if you crave comfort food on a winters day or eve. You can eat their clam chowder with a fork. The Coleslaw is lightly dressed rather than drowning in sauce and some wizard in the kitchen understands the proper soaking of a roast beef au jus sandwich. 20 stars....
K
Kim B
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Liked
• 26-06-19
• DoorDash review
I've ordered from Crogan's a few times recently. Overall it was a great value. I was totally enthralled with the charbroiled salmon w/quinoa and green beans and would definitely order it again.
I wasn't too impressed with the steak salad or crab cakes, though. While I requested my steak medium rare, there wasn't even a hint of pink. And the crab cakes were bland and more filler than crabmeat. I was disappointed 😞
I'll stick with the charbroiled salmon, though, because it was utterly delicious!
M
Merah M
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Loved
• 26-03-16
• DoorDash order
Portion size of the Braised Short Rib meal was huge for the price. 2 sides spinach and potatoes. The taste for was a 10/10. The spinach was a bit bland but paired well with the beef and potatoes! The restaurant even added 2 complimentary cookies. Can't wait to order again ! Also, the crab cakes tastes
J
Jamie L
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 26-04-19
• DoorDash order
Perfect comfort food and my most-ordered restaurant on DoorDash. Try the sublime braised short rib and the reuben with delightfully crisp fries. I also get the French dip, and two orders of calamari and potato skins. Cool people, too; the way they handled an occasional request is really like a true neighborhood stalwart (like giving me a table ketchup when I said I was out). Thanks for all the food, guys.
A
Ann H
8 contributions
Loved
• 23-11-18
• DoorDash order
I just tried Crogans after not going there for years because I had a couple bad experiences with very dry bread (about 10+ years back) and it was excellent; I think they changed ownership. The Quesadilla had a wonderful flaky crust and was a generous serving (My only recommendation would be to cut down the oil a bit in the crust.); it far exceedd the quality of similar items at the two nearby Mexican restaurants in the Montclair District. The Black Bean Soup had an excellent flavor, but I felt more like it was an $8 serving than a $10+ serving size, but I would buy it again on the Happy Hour (2-5 pm) deal. My only complaint is to remember to comply with AB1276 and ONLY PROVIDE UTENSILS on request; I usually rate down 5 star restaurants to 4 stars when this happens, but because they gave me two cookies with a nice thank you note, I won't downgrade the rating.
