This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Checking if the site connection is secured...
4.6(500+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(500+)•
$$•Pizzeria
GAINES STREET PIES WAS CREATED BY TWO LOCAL GUYS WHO WANTED TO CREATE THE BEST PIZZA IN TALLAHASSEE. “Ingredient by ingredient and recipe by recipe, we worked until we found the very best. We started …
I always liked the pizza here. i considered it the third best in town behind Barnaby's and Decent Pizza, but then Barnaby's closed, and I had Decent Pizza again recently, and it's not as good as I remember. So now Gaines Street has the best pie in town that I know of
E
Edward L
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 26-08-26
• DoorDash order
Ordered build your own pepperoni extra cheese 4.75 for like twelve pepperoni and almost $6 for extra cheese and got regular cheese, pizza was burnt in places and very greasy. If I wasn't just passing through id say I'll never order here again
K
Kelly S
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-12-10
• DoorDash order
The cheese on the margherita pizza was so sparse that I had to apologize to my guests. Cant believe I spent $30 on that pizza. This was disappointing. The Ceasar salad was good. Garlic knots were dryer than normal.
S
Sherry T
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
Liked
• 26-02-21
• DoorDash order
Those jalepeno poppers are AMAZING. The pie was delicious. Crispy crust, perfect amount of sauce and toppings.
N
Nyssa B
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 25-03-30
• DoorDash order
First time eating GSP. We personally just were not impressed. Pizza was paper thin and very greasy. However the taste was good, cooked well. The price was pretty average. Ive heard many people like this place but it wasnt for us.
