This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Checking if the site connection is secured...
4.6(5k+)•
DashPass•
Ice Cream & Gelato
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(5k+)•
$$•Ice Cream & Gelato
The Ice Cream Cottage, located on Montauk Highway in historic Mastic, New York on Long Island, first opened its doors in March of 1990. The Ice Cream Cottage has won numerous awards since then. The Ic…
We were all so excited for the deliciousness that is ICE CREAM COTTAGE that I forgot to take a picture. Every bite was absolutely mouth watering. I got the cannoli ice cream for the first time and I almost cried happy tears it was that good!!!! Defin get any flavor, theyre all amazing!
T
Tara T
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-04-26
• DoorDash order
This cup was so small, I paid for 4 scoops of ice cream. It was more like 2 scoops. Terrible rip off.
J
Jen R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 23-10-13
• DoorDash order
There was only banana ice cream with walnuts and I chose four, there was little maybe cookies and cream...? Not sure.
Also, there was like a cotton candy taste layer underneath the rainbow sprinkles. Barely any wet peanut sauce. Total bummer. Where were all the ice cream flavors???
L
Lennox R
5 contributions
Loved
• 21-12-31
• DoorDash order
Excellent ice cream. Only way to go if your in Suffolk county. They make carvel look like a joke . A little pricey though
M
Michele T
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-01-15
• DoorDash review
Unfortunately was not good. Very fake taste to the ice cream and toppings. We threw them in the garbage. Have never had this experience with ice cream. We ordered sundaes with whipped cream however, the cups are too small and the covers smashed everything and disintegrated the whipped cream. It was non existent. Can't see how anyone who likes ice cream would like the taste of these flavors. Pistachio ice cream, like emerald green color. Fake flavoring and after taste is really bad, even chocolate was fake tasting. We sampled 6 different flavors and none of them were good. Reading the website, Newsday says best ice cream on Long Island? They need to replace the food critic. Really wanted to like it...
