This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Ok. First of all... the pies are ginormous. Seriously. There are two of us here. I ordered two pizzas thinking they would be along the lines of where we are from (about 14inches) and we would have pizza for two or three days.
No no. Nope. E. Nor. Mous. My spouse and I split two slices for dinner. and thought we were going to die. We have food for a week off these suckers and we aren't mad about.
Their red sauce tastes fresh, perfectly acidic and sweet, and the right amount for the crust. Their pepperoni and sausage are both delicious and the right kind of oily for that classic pizza taste. The crust is incredibly chewy and soft. It reminded me of living in NYC many years ago and made me so happy.
The Mootz Pie? Crazy good. So much garlic. So much cheese. That great bite in through the layers. Next time i would ask for the red sauce on it too to help cut through the richness of everything but holy bejeebers this pie is delicious. Also suggest adding basil or mushrooms. It gives that little something extra.
You can't go wrong here. We aren't locals and don't order out often as it is so we are both really happy we came across Paulie Gee's.
And tip the staff!
D
Dan L
1 contributions
Loved
• 26-08-16
• DoorDash order
Cheese Pie just the way I like it. Plenty of sauce (crushed tomatoes), good cheese, thin crisp crust. Enough leftovers for dinner. I bet it's going to come out really good from the reheat in the Ninja.
M
Michael M
7 contributions
Liked
• 26-01-08
• DoorDash order
Thank you chefs and staff for best Pizza in Philly, followed my special request to the "T" and it had to be one of the best pies I've had ffom Paulie Gee's which in my quest to find the best pie in Philly always has me reordering from here. Best sauce , cheese, crust and toppings. Always fresh and best quality ingredients.
C
Chelsea G
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 24-09-06
• DoorDash order
Best pizza in philly. I don't even like pepperoni pizza BUT I love theirs!! It's the little roni's too btw. Every time my man from GA comes out here we get this.<3 price is worth it because the pizza is hugeeee
M
Michael T
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 23-01-08
• DoorDash order
Good heavens I can't believe I can get such great pizza this so late on a Saturday. Great "non gluteny" dough that doesn't fill you up. Well cooked. It's a slightly wetter pizza with a tremendous sauce that has a little kick. It's huge. A true extra large pizza. Can't say enough great things about this place.
