This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint brings real New York-style pizza to the West Coast with crispy-yet-chewy crusts and bold, nostalgic flavor. But we’re more than just pizza — our menu features handcrafted pastas…
The gluten free pizza is pretty awesome. The crust is thin and the cheese seems sparse, so I didn't know if I'd like the pizza. It's really good. Ask for extra cheese if you prefer your pizza to be covered in it. I told them, "The more sauce the better." So, they may have put more on mine than normal. I loved it.
T
Tiffany G
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-02-11
• DoorDash order
The ziti was a monumental disappointment. It tasted as though something was spoiled or "off." It smelled bad too. I ended up throwing it out. What a waste of money. I would not recommend this. The meatballs were small and seemed as though they were frozen and reheated. They weren't tasty either. Two, small meatballs came in a huge container with a bit of sauce and arrived cold.
S
Sophie L
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 24-02-23
• DoorDash order
Im confused by the high rating of this place, my entire order was poor. I ordered the BBQ chicken and it arrived with approx 5 cubes of chicken on it, hidden under the cheese. If I wanted a cheese and red onion pizza i would have ordered that. The pizza was also lukewarm as it's not delivered in a pizza box bag.
The "newyork cheesecake" was an absolute joke. $6 for a slice the size of the palm of my hand.... pictures attached. And sadly the taste did not compensate for the tiny size.
Really disappointed and will not be ordering again.
J
Joan K
18 contributions
Loved
• 22-12-12
• DoorDash order
The meatballs are always tender and delicious, I'm addicted. The croutons & ranch dressing are 100% of why I get the Caesar salad, the lettuce is great but the croutons & dressing are amazing.
R
Rachel P
Local Expert • 48 contributions
Loved
• 23-07-23
• DoorDash order
This Bronx expat is impressed. Since I moved to LA, it's harder to find pizza like I'm used to back east. It's definitely more expensive out here too. But this place is a gem that makes pizza just like you're back on either side of the Hudson. Perfect treat for New Yorkers and New Jerseyans feeling homesick!
