Hot Cookie has been a Castro institution since 1997, with a vast assortment of freshly baked, chewy cookies, the infamous Penis and Vagina Cookies, and a wall of hot customers posing in our unique Hot…
these cookies are so soft & decadent. the Mini Saint Ginger Snap Cookie should've been 2 for 1.50 but that aside they were SO GOOD! perfectly chewy. Peanut Butter Cookie is soft & rich. Cookie of the Month (chocolate & mint) doesn't taste like mint at all in my opinion, just a nice chocolate cookie with some type of frosting and sprinkles. if you're someone who just wants a chocolate cookie & hates mint, you'll be able to enjoy it
M
Markus A
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 01/03/26
• DoorDash order
It's all good. Just get it. No regrets. It wouldn't be San Francisco without Hot Cookie. Consistently tasty and plenty of cookie in each cookie. Butch Bar's are absolutely evil they're so good.
M
Maureen M
Emerging Expert • 39 contributions
Liked
• 01/02/26
• DoorDash order
TheWhite Chocolate Macadamia Cookie is delicious, as it always is. Rich and satisfying, but not overly sweet.
Their Oatmeal Raisin Cookie is my favorite! it's better than minewere when I made them! Lots of raisins, they are soft and feel fresh from the oven
Yum!
J
Jonathan V
1 contributions
Liked
• 13/05/26
• DoorDash order
The size of the Chocolate Frosted Brownie compared to large cookies at the same price point makes me feel cheated.
I should have gotten another cookie 😞
J
Jehmima C
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Loved
• 19/06/25
• DoorDash order
I love Hot Cookie! I always order the Hunky Monkey Cookie because it is gluten free (and delicious) but just discovered they have a new gluten free cookie as well, the Monster Cookie! The bakery replaced the Hunky Monkey with a Monster Cookie because they could not fulfill the whole order of Hunky Monkeys, and I am happy to report that the Monster Cookie is a great cookie as well! Glad to now have two gluten free options!
