Mike and binnie di sabato opened emelio's as a local restaurant and bar in 1960. emelio's has been a local hangout for generations of customers thanks to its courteous service and traditional cooking.…
I LOVE Emelio's! The crew, especially Brandon, is awesome. Truly great people making what I consider to be the best thin crust Pizza anywhere in Ohio. In more than 8 years of patronage, I have yet to be disappointed. The Special Salad is also a winner and is a great addition to any pizza or sub. Seriously, give them a try. I can't imagine you'll be unsatisfied. Emelio's is a true gem!
A
Amber C
3 contributions
Loved
• 01/10/25
• DoorDash order
This is hands down the best tavern-style pizza I’ve had in Columbus! The sauce had great flavor, the pepperonis were perfectly crispy, and the thin crust was sturdy and stayed crisp without folding. Every bite had the right balance of crunch and flavor. Definitely my new go-to spot for pizza!
M
Molly C
9 contributions
Loved
• 17/10/24
• DoorDash order
I have always loved this place! And to be able to get it at home is wonderful! It's the best in Columbus. The Special Salad is absolutely one of a kind! I would have taken pics...but I was too excited to eat. It's been a long time since I had one, and the quality is perfect and unchanged. Thanks for being so wonderful!
J
j h
3 contributions
Loved
• 02/08/23
• DoorDash order
So good. been looking for a place in columbus similar to my hometown pizza. this is the closest i've found. theyre both similar but unique in very different, great ways. please give this play a try. the all the way pizza is fantastic and my go to. my new fav place in columbus.
W
Wyatt J
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 03/08/25
• DoorDash review
We placed an order that included a pizza, a large salad, garlic bread, two subs, two cans of pop, and five sides of ranch. Unfortunately, the salad and all five ranches were missing from our order.
The two cans of pop cost over $5, which seems excessive. Both subs were overcooked and came without any sauce. On top of that, the pizza we received was incorrect and undercooked.
We used to really enjoy ordering from this place, but this experience was extremely disappointing. The food quality has gone downhill, and the prices are now way too high for what you get.
