The NY Slice
4.3(2k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.3(2k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
In July 2011, NY Slice was launched as a pizza truck (Manhattan, also known as "Manny" that wants to bring authentic New York-style brick oven pizza to Indianapolis. Our pizza became a hot topic for I…
Full Menu
11:30 am - 6:45 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
16" Pizza
$21.23
•87% (55)
#1 Most liked
16" Buffalo Chicken
$28.31
20" Da Big Greek
$34.21
20" Margherita
$33.03
20" Formaggi
$33.03
16" Formaggi
$29.49
•100% (11)
Reviews2k+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.3
of 5 stars
J
Jakim B
Local Expert • 46 contributionsLoved
• 10/07/26The best pizza in Indiana and the whole Midwest. The base house sauce is incredible plus the balance of flavors. I suggest an extra cheese with garlic and green peppers or just extra cheese and garlic if you want a rich tasting but not heavy pizza with the NY thin crust style. How they place the minced garlic is always done perfectly. When most lame pizza chains don't even offer a garlic topping unless it's on the crust or a highly processed side cup. And the pizza joints who do offer garlic toppings always have LAME base sauce and cheap toppings flavoring. The NY Slice IS THE BEST PIZZA JOINT PERIOD.
J
Jakim B
Local Expert • 46 contributionsLoved
• 16/08/26Da Big Greek is their best vegetarian pizza. Exceptional combination of flavors. No other pizza joint in Indy comes close to this place.
T
Tabitha S
1 contributionsLoved
• 03/04/25Got the 20" Formaggi added pepperoni and ham. NY Slice is always amazing every time I go there whether I get a full pizza or just a slice. Fantastic pizza! The owner is a wonderful man. Great business all around.
T
T.D. M
Emerging Expert • 13 contributionsLoved
• 23/10/21The best pizza in Indiana hands down. The Sauce is mind blowing, the salads are fresh and big. The real special thing at this place is the sauce. I dream about it.
L
Luke S
1 contributionsLoved
• 14/01/26This is my absolute favorite pizza place ever. It's the most authentic and fresh New York style pizza in Indianapolis. I am here all the time and love how the owner treats everyone as family.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store