Goodfellas Pizza & Pasta
4.6(1k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
4.6(1k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:30 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Build Your Own Pizza (Large 18")
$24.99
•87% (71)
#1 Most liked
Build Your Own Pizza (Medium 16")
$22.99
•90% (32)
Da Godfather
$26.99
•81% (43)
#3 Most liked
Build Your Own Pizza (Small 14")
$20.99
•76% (43)
The Goodfella
$25.99
•100% (23)
Jumbo Buffalo Wings
$10.95
•90% (30)
Reviews1k+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
J
Jen D
1 contributionsLoved
• 21/02/25The Caesar salad is AMAZING! They use big chunks of seasoned bread for the croutons and the dressing is the perfect amount. The cheesy garlic bread pairs perfect with the salad. And the pizza, each time I've had it I've never been disappointed. Not to mention the staff is always really sweet and nice.
T
twinsdad A
2 contributionsLiked
• 22/05/26Although the pizza is my favorite food here, the garlic clove with the funny name and the wedge salad are probably the best I've had outside of St. Louis. Pinball and a jukebox and a pool table and a nearby deli and it's happy days in 2026 for me and my dog
A
Anna R
1 contributionsLiked
• 07/12/24The pizza was delicious. The Cesar salad "large" was not good value. The portion was disappointing for the price.
C
Cami C
Emerging Expert • 21 contributionsLoved
• 16/02/24Their pizza is always amazing - the only issue is I have is when youre doing a Build Your Own Pizza (Large 18"), each topping is $2.50 and they barely sprinkle it on. If there were more of the toppings I chose, it would be the perfect pizza!!
T
Tamara W
7 contributionsLoved
• 30/10/21Always a great Pizza at Goodfellas! We love their Pesto so this time we branched out and got the Pesto Fettuccini-- Yum! Also, if you haven't tried the Vito Corleone you should, rosemary potatoes with pesto on pizza is amazing.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pizzas
Build Your Own Pizzas
Made with house-made hand-tossed dough prepared fresh daily & a special blend of Italian spices (*priced as two toppings).
Appetizers & Sides
Salads
All dressings & sauces are made in house.
Calzone
Pasta & Specialties
Served with french bread and compound butter. Sauces: Marinara, meat sauce, pesto, cream or vodka sauce.
Sandwiches
Add fries for an extra charge.