More Than Pudding - 3020 W Pensacola St
4.7(200+)•
DashPass•
Dessert & Sweet Treats•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(200+)•
Dessert & Sweet Treats
More Than Pudding was born out of our customers’ love for our signature frozen puddings. What started with fan favorites like Key Lime Pie and Dirty Red Velvet has now expanded to offer even more deli…
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
4 count Bread Pudding Bundle
$30.00
4 count NY Style Jumbo Cookie Bundle
$30.00
2 count Bread Pudding Bundle
$15.00
Large Cup (12 oz)
$13.00
•96% (26)
#3 Most liked
Medium Cup (8 oz)
$10.40
•93% (32)
#2 Most liked
Bread Pudding
$7.50
•95% (42)
#1 Most liked
Reviews200+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
H
Hannah A
Local Expert • 24 contributionsLoved
• 11/01/25This is even better than I was expecting. Some of the best bread pudding I've ever had. It came warm. I got the cookie butter bread pudding an bananas foster custard pudding. I cant wait to try other flavors.soooo delicious!!!!
R
Robert A
7 contributionsLiked
• 27/02/26This honestly my favorite desert restaurant in tallahassee. Hands down. They got a solid product that's worth the cost and I've never had a problem with my groceries. The chocolate chip crookie is amazing!
N
Nico H
Emerging Expert • 21 contributionsLiked
• 06/12/25SPEECHLESS!! This was my first time trying this place and I HIGHLY recommend!!. It was hot and fresh the portions was great the taste was amazing, And the Cookie butter cheesecake was absolutely amazing as well as the Strawberry Bread Pudding and Raspberry one not to mention they had brilliant communication and let me know something I got was out of order and let me choose a substitute! I will definitely be ordering again
J
J W
2 contributionsLiked
• 17/07/26Idk why anyone would put a cookie on a croissant. The concept seems weird. Honestly I just ate the cookie off of the croissant. Seems like you would have a better experience and better value just having multiple cookies without the croissant. But, the cookie itself was delicious. Pudding was good too. Not super outstanding, but a decent value & good flavors. Unique & not too sweet. Overall I'd give it 3.75 out of 5 stars.
D
Denisha R
2 contributionsLoved
• 13/03/26The banana pudding from this place is one of my favorites! Literally the best place to go to if you have a sweet tooth. The owner is very understanding, generous and knows how to operate her business the right way!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Pudding Stackers
A cup of frozen pudding, cookies, toppings and whipped cream.
Gourmet Drinks
Bundles
Love our cookies and bread puddings? Get them cheaper by ordering a bundle!
PoundCake Slices
Selection of moist, flavorful, homemade poundcake slices to choose from.
Cheesecake
Creamy rich cheesecake in various flavors
NY Bakery Style Cookies
6 oz fresh baked cookies.
Frozen Custard Puddings
Select the desired creamy custard pudding, size, and toppings.
Baked Treats
Rice Puddings
Select the desired creamy rice pudding, size, and toppings.
Take Home Containers
Includes seasonal flavors.