Marley’s Gotham Grill
4.6(4k+)•
DashPass•
Italian-American•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(4k+)•
$$•Italian-American
Marley’s Gotham Grill is located in the heart of the the lively Hackettstown area of New Jersey.
The Star Ledger’s Munchmobile recently ranked Marley’s as one of Jersey’s best for their “big, moist, c…
Full Menu
11:30 am - 8:55 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Wings
$19.50+
•91% (457)
#1 Most liked
The New Jersey Steak Sandwich
$18.95
•95% (48)
California Turkey Wrap
$18.50
Big! Big! Bacon Burger
$19.95
•100% (7)
Momma Jo's Best Damn! Buffalo Sandwich
$18.50
•95% (24)
Pierogies
$16.95
•86% (15)
Reviews4k+ ratings • 60+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
M
Martha S
10 contributionsLoved
• 18/06/26The Orange Pecan Salsad is delicious and refreshing. The grilled chicken on top was especially good. A lot of the time when you get grilled chicken on top of a salad it's kind of dry and doesn't have much flavor, but this chicken has some herbs/spices on it that are delicious.
The toffee cake is heavenly. Definitely recommend!
C
Corinne R
Emerging Expert • 10 contributionsDidn't like
• 26/04/25Not sure if it was a bad night, or if Marley's changed their recipes or if they have a new supplier, but the food was not what were used to receiving. The burgers were dry and the flavor was off. The new Pickle Balls were just okay, definitely not worth 15$ for only 4 of them. Bummed if this is the new norm
L
Lydian H
11 contributionsDidn't like
• 07/04/24I don't know that I'd order it again. The only thing that was decent was The Gotham. The portions were weird ... with the burgers we got maybe 10 fries on the side (for $15). The Boneless Wings with Fries were soaked in a sauce that had no flavor. The Child's Pizza was soggy. The Rainbow Falafel Wrap and Poutine were very bland and over-salted. The dasher told me that the wait times were bad, and that he could see that our food was just sitting and getting cold.
L
Lori A
48 contributionsLiked
• 20/08/22Disappointed in the Caprese sandwich. It was grilled like a panini and the mozzarella was like rubber. There was only 2 thin slices of tomato and basil was nowhere to be found. We will never order that again.
J
Joel P
2 contributionsDidn't like
• 06/03/23The second time getting food from here, my first time was so amazing that I had to go again but this time the food that was not edible, the wings tasted like the plastic container it was in which leaves me to think it was wings that was left under a heating lamp for so long it dried out any flavor or taste to the Wings except for the plastic taste. The disco fries were not fresh and was soggy to the point where it was unappetizing. The Meat Lovers was sloppy and thrown toget with way too much toppings. As if door dashing isnt expensive enough. I would say the only plus I spoke to a Miguel and he assured me iwill be refunded in yhe morning, ill be back to follow up with how this was resolved.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store