Delicious as always. Hits the spot everytime. Tried the Pico de Gallo Dog and the BBQ Sandwich this time around for myself, while my employee had the Chicago Dog along with the Coney Mac n Cheese, and we each had the Green River drinks. Forgot to snap a pic but it was worth it!!
Larry D
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 16/07/25
• DoorDash order
Coney Island is ALWAYS 5 stars yet my only slight nitpick with Taco Salad is the OVER abundance of lettuce. I understand it's a salad & lettuce is cheap filler which is why Im not lowering rating nor complaining just small nitpick. Outstanding service & food for decades in Galesburg.
A
Amber S
Local Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 26/07/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering here and I wanted to try something outside the box. The Coney Slaw Dog was absolutely delicious. The Taco Dog was my favorite! And the Pico de Gallo Dog was very good. A bit too much cilantro but flavor was unique. I definitely recommend ordering from this longstanding neighborhood favorite!
D
Darrell G
1 contributions
Liked
• 25/02/26
• DoorDash order
Coney Island is a regular stop for my wife and I. They serve only quality dogs and that makes a big difference. The signature Coney dogs are great and they make a mean Chicago dog as well. There's good reason this place has been around as long as it has! Try it and you'll be a regular too!
Larry D
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 12/07/25
• DoorDash order
I had never had Taco Dog before so ordered it to try & Instantly regretted after taking a bite, only cuz I should have ordered more!It's is THE best hotdog I've ever eaten. 2 Coney Dogs were gobbled up by my fiance & Chicago Dog is a favorite of mine before tasting the Taco Dog. Excellent all around as always.
