Absolutely delicious! It's hard to find authentic NY style bagels in this area and these were wonderful. Fresh, flavorful, and the cream cheeses were super yummy. Will be a loyal regular customer now!
L
Leighann Z
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
Loved
• 13/01/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Avocado toast on Sourdough Bread with the addition of 2 fried eggs. Let me tell you, it was absolutely DELICIOUS!!!
And the Crispy, Crunchy (made just right) Hash Brown On The Side was a great addition to complete a great breakfast!
Great size portions of fresh ingredients. Worth the price and I will definitely order this again!
N
Nick R
8 contributions
Loved
• 12/08/26
• DoorDash order
Bagelman is always consistent, fresh and tastes awesome. I have reached out to the owner on numerous occasions and he has literally customized sandwiches just for me. That's what's nice about having a family business here in New Milford! Keep it up guys!!
T
Theresa M
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 26/08/26
• DoorDash order
Food was cold..Bacon egg and cheese was the most pathetic sandwich I've ever seen. Bacon was raw, barely even a whole egg and slice of cheese on there.
M
Makayla L
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Liked
• 17/01/26
• DoorDash order
tha Breakfast Bagel - 3 Item was delicious! the Hash Brown On The Side was quite cold beside that the taste was good. now the Refresher was ok the taste it a little weird. if you love starbucks refresher and try this one it's not good.
