I ordered the Gnocchi Dinner and it was delicious! The sauce was much better than the first time I had it. The meatballs were excellent. The salad is always on point with the rolled mozzarella, and the house dressing. Generous portion with enough for leftovers. Very satisfied.
K
Katie P
4 contributions
Liked
• 16/01/26
• DoorDash order
It was good, just wish i could customize more, ie. take the peppers off, have a sauce on the fingers, and change the dressing. the portion was huge for the price! the salad itself was very fresh, the fingers were hot, and delicious. if they add more customization options I would definitely order again.
D
Deborah P
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Liked
• 16/05/26
• DoorDash order
My food arrived cold. I still ate a third of it. The Gnocchi and meatball were perfect. The sauce didn't taste homemade. A little disappointed. It tasted like RedPack which isn't horrible. Rumor was it is supposed to taste like Michael's, a local restaurant that went out of business. IYKYK. But overall I did enjoy the food, regardless, and would order from them again. I do suggest that they add Italian bread and butter to the dinner.
M
Mike D
Local Expert • 110 contributions
Loved
• 11/10/25
• DoorDash order
To me, Colbert's pub is probably one of the best finds on the DoorDash app in the Niagara Falls NY area. Everything that I've ordered from there has been wonderful good size portions and very reasonably priced Culbert's pub is a home run.
J
Jeannie E
18 contributions
Liked
• 22/02/26
• DoorDash order
The best pasta & meatball in the area.. the meatballs taste like my grandma made them!
Never disappointed