In Gainesville, Florida, John Gillespie created the first Five Star Pizza in 1988.The commitment to quality at Five Star Pizza has never wavered; regardless of the cost of ingredients, we only use the…
Live local to these guys... LOVE their pizza, (really, any is good!) great wings, quick service (delivery & in store), plus friendly. Never had an issue with any orders. Just all around good experiences with them so, I'll continue to be a loyal customer! Their specialty pizzas ( CHICKEN ALFREDO , Philly cheesesteak, pepperoni powerhouse) should be illegal, they are THAT GOOD!! 🤯🤌🏼🤌🏼🧨💥🔥🤤
K
Krystal M
Local Expert • 85 contributions
Loved
• 28/02/26
• DoorDash order
my pizza arrived looking perfect! the toppings are evenly spread on the entire pizza and they put just the right amount too. its a huge pizza, perfect for the two of us. it's fresh and hot as well so for the distance, that is a big bonus as well. I definitely would order from here again.Five Star Pizza has always been a favorite of ours and they still don't disappoint
D
Donna S
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
1st time in years Five Star pizza has disappointed me. Horrible pizza. I ordered a specialty Hawaiian pizza and paid price. You delivered a 12" MEDIUM plain cheese with a thin cardboard stale crust. Cheese topping was burned along with no sauce to even mention. Unless you make this right your pizza place that I've always sworn to be great will be a NO STAR go to. Sad to see this!
M
Michelle P
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Liked
• 17/12/25
• DoorDash order
12" MEDIUM pepperoni & cheese; GARLIC ROLLS w/ MARINARA; CINNAMON ROLLS w/ ICING - all delicious, fresh , not too pricy, pizza enough for hubby and I. Would order again.
J
Jo N
12 contributions
Liked
• 15/07/26
• DoorDash order
First time I have been disappointed with my order. The label on the box is correct, but the pizza inside was wrong. I ordered extra cheese, sausage, green & black olives, green peppers and onions. what I got was a cheese and sausage and mushrooms. I spent forever picking off those nasty mushrooms! The pizza was still good. It arrived piping hot and fast. Five Star is still my favorite pizza. Just sorely disappointed with this order.
