Gumby's Pizza has created a solid reputation for high-quality food, excellent customer service, and amazing value.
Gumby's Pizza works hard on the foundation building blocks of its business, much like…
Pokey sticks were really good, as were the two 20" Build Your Own Pizza and 20" Bbq Chicken Pizza were great as well! Way more food than we anticipated, but nobody left hungry!
Lerena W
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 16/04/26
• DoorDash order
The pizza showed up practically bare, with barely any toppings—especially the meat. There were maybe six tiny pieces of sausage and a few slices of pepperoni, which is honestly unacceptable for what you pay. On top of that, it tasted awful. This was a huge letdown and nothing like the Gumby’s I remember.
Mind you, this is suppose to be a Galore Pizza
S
Sariye V
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 21/11/22
• DoorDash order
Wow the 5 Wings we're GREAT!! Fall off the bone very yummy.. but I will say for 5 of them it was very $$$! Ranch was pricy for no reason.. doesn't wings come with sauce!? Other wise the Philly Cheese Steak Pasta was not the best. It was dry very little sauce only chz was on top no flavor. Also barely any meat honestly it tasted like it was noodles and bell peppers. Never received my mountain dew.
E
ella d
1 contributions
Didn't like
• today
• DoorDash order
This place used to be great but recently there's been a massive drop off in quality, pizzas barely have any toppings, the stoner pizza which used to be literally covered in toppings now has slices that maybe have a piece of pepperoni and a fry or two on it, ridiculous to pay $45 for essentially a large cheese pizza which is crazy disappointing because this used to be the best pizza place in IC
A
Amber B
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 07/08/26
• DoorDash order
Stoner Pie Pizza was absolutely amazing and very filling, 12 Pokey dots tasted amazing as well will definitely be ordering again!!
