Nostalgic Pizza Shop !!!!!
Specializing in Artisan Pan Pizzas, Epic Strombolis, and Jumbo Wings.
Located in Olde Tollgate Village
2535 South Queen Street
York, PA 17402
The pizza was good. Very heavy on the herbs but I really like that. The crust had a great flavor with some crunch but also a bit too chewy. I'd order again.
A
Angie T
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/07/26
• DoorDash order
Ordered 3 pizzas. The cheese pizza was black. The sausage on the second pizza was black and crispy. Only the onion pizza was cooked correctly and tasty. Not sure why 2 of three were burnt. Also a significant difference in size between the 3. All were small pizzas. Probably not order again for delivery. May try in person. Pics show burnt cheese pizza and onion pizza that wasn't burnt.
M
Meghan K
1 contributions
Loved
• 13/06/26
• DoorDash order
The Kiki bread was awesome (wanted to try cauliflower crust this round- didnt disappoint!), the pizza was loaded with pepperoni & pineapple (so good! Not ya regular pineapple!) & our 5 year old housed like half a large cheese pizza (leftovers for lunch)... win/win/win for all involved!
J
John K
1 contributions
Loved
• 19/06/26
• DoorDash order
If you have a chance to eat here, ambience is awesome. Pretty cool pizza joint with great bread/pizza. Thanks!
