Reuben was delicious thin sliced corned beef, could've used more cheese and sauerkraut but overall yummy. The chili was also really good, not spicy just a lot of good flavor. I added some shredded cheese to take it to the next level. The McAlister’s Famous Tea with peach puree was 10/10! I also got the bowl of Country Potato Soup, which I personally don't think was worth the $8+. Didn't have a lot of bacon or chives in it and no cheese at all. Consistency was way off and was very bland. I'd also like to note it had a very SOUR taste, I'm not sure if it always tastes like that since I've never ordered here before but I've never had Country Potato Soup with that flavor so it was definitely off putting. I don't think it was bad just not what I was expecting out of a classic potato soup. Besides the odd soup flavor it was very filling and I had leftovers the next day and it was all wrapped well. I would definitely order here again and just go with a different soup.
S
Stefanie C
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/07/23
• DoorDash order
The Side Garden Salad and Veggie Chili were good. I got the bowl and it was a generous amount for the price. Container came wrapped in plastic so it wouldn't spill out or open in the bag. Was still hot when it arrived, very quick delivery. Salad ingredients were fresh.
K
K B
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 16/07/26
• DoorDash order
My veggie spud came with no butter & unfortunately I had no butter either. It was very dry and the veggies were tasteless. There was only one large piece of broccoli on the spud. It would have been nice to have more or at least cut it up. For the price there was not alot of veggies on it. Definitely didn't look like the picture on the menu.
Turkey melt presentation was real bad. Sandwhich was squished and looked thrown together. There was a large thick chuck if avocado on one side of the sandwhich. It would have been nice if the avocado was cut thinner and placed throughout the sandwhich. I also excepted more toppings and meat . The sandwhich was good it just would have been better with the avocado cut and placed correctly and more veggies & meat. This was my first time trying this restaurant. Not a good first impression at all.
T
Tiffany T
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 20/06/24
• DoorDash order
Ordered Choose 2: French dip & Spud. I received about 1/4 inch of au jus sauce (didn't spill out of bag), the sandwich was super small and they didn't include the pickle. The potato was hard and dry. Not worth the 25.00 to deliver it.
J
Jessica B
Emerging Expert • 26 contributions
Didn't like
• 19/01/24
• DoorDash order
Worst Choose 2 I've ever gotten from McAlisters. The 1/2 French Dip was two small slices of dry roast beef between two squeezed pieces of bread and no cheese. The pickle slice was bigger than the slices of meat! The inside of the burned potato was covered in tasty vegetables and cheese. Too bad. I've eaten here so many times and the food was great. This was a bad experience.
