Everything is always delicious and correct!! Can't ask for better!!! Bagels are so good... their tuna salad platter is incredible! Always consistently good food, and service! The owners are such gracious people!
J
Jennifer B
28 contributions
Loved
• 02/04/25
• DoorDash order
I usually order the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel and it's delicious but it was lunch time and I wanted to try something new. I ordered the 1. Reuben sandwich with everything on it, extra toasted on the bread and it was soooo good. It also came with Salsa and chips and the chips were still warm when it was delivered. They really make your food as your dasher arrives so your food it's still hot when it comes to you. I love this place. highly recommend!!!!
D
Danielle F
3 contributions
Liked
• 07/06/26
• DoorDash order
everything is always delicious, hot and fresh. They always get my order correct and their bagels are incredible!!
T
Terrance W
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
Didn't like
• 17/05/26
• DoorDash order
I've ordered from here for over a year the last 2 Sundays my toasted bagel is barely toasted and taste like the super market Thomas's very disappointed after ordering here for over a year I may as well order the frozen bagels from Dunkin' Donuts
R
Raquel A
4 contributions
Loved
• 16/05/26
• DoorDash order
Bagel Boy is my favorite place for years ... they are very attentive with my orders since we have a few allergies.
Best place in Nutley and surrounded areas.
You won't regret make them your favorite place.
