The pizza was delicious, as always! Crust is crunchy outside with just enough softness inside. Yum! A perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The steak & cheese egg rolls were a teenie bit dry on the outside, but the texture & taste inside made them delicious. I was surprised I enjoyed the cheese dipping sauce, but it was different and delicious. The garlic knots? Sooo warm, soft and perfectly flavorful. The desserts were a real indulgence and the portions were perfect. Highly recommend Pappy's for choices between traditional pizza night favorites and other unexpected options!!
Pappy's has long been a Wednesday afternoon Dad & Son eat-in visit. Cruising up & down Elm St as a teen in the 80s, all of us ended the night there. Looking forward to the next order, for sure!
E
Eileen H
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
The Haddock Sub consisted of flat, tasteless pieces of what appeared to be frozen not fresh fish. Not a drop of tartar sauce on the bread and what I think was supposed to be chopped tomato? I'm not even sure that was haddock.
The Spaghetti was ok, not much sauce at all but the meatballs were decent.
The Create Your Own Pizza or Calzone! was huge and probably the most palatable item. For the amount of $ spent, this definitely was not worth it.
M
Michael J
2 contributions
Loved
• 26/03/26
• DoorDash order
THIS HAS TO BE TOP 3 FOOD PLACES I EVER EVER ORDERED FROM THE Steak & Cheese! BEING PACKED FULL TO THE BRIM WITH STEAK TO THE TENDERNESS OF THE CHICKEN TENDERS MY WIFE ORDERED AND THE SEASONED TATER TOTS ARE ABSOLUTELY AMAZING AS WELL! Food was still very warm when it got here and I 100% would order again
A
Austen P
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 14/06/26
• DoorDash order
this was the best Create Your Own Pizza or Calzone! I've ever had
huge and yet amazing. perfect about a cheese and ricotta. absolutely loved it. pepperoni was spot on
L
Lindsey C
3 contributions
Loved
• 21/04/25
• DoorDash order
The mozzer sticks were crispy and the cheese pull was out of this world!!! The chicken wings were crispy and the meat juicy! Awesome as always!!!
