At Pelato we proudly serve authentic Brooklyn Italian fare, reimagined in a small plate & casual atmosphere. We embrace the richness of Italian culture, infused with the unmistakable spirit of Brookly…
Hands down the best pancake I’ve ever had! 🥞😍 It tasted so fresh, wholesome, and delicious. Light, fluffy, and not heavy at all. I could seriously eat this every single day and never get tired of it!
V
Virginia P
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 18/12/24
• DoorDash order
The pasta portions were so small! The appetizer prices and portions were very expected, and thank heavens I ordered apps or we would have been hungry. The Radiatori Vodka was delicious (though spicier than most things made with Calabrian chilis), but it was the smallest portion of pasta I have ever eaten. I know it is a small plates restaurant, but I don't know how anyone one could have split the Bucatini Cacio e Pepe the way it was plated given the size. Would have rather paid more for a larger portion of pasta than been unsatisfied.
M
Mary M
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 20/05/25
• DoorDash order
The pasta tastes good however the portion size was more like thst of an appetizer, this was disappointing especially for the price.
The stuffed mushrooms were decent.
I dont think I'd order from here again but I would consder going into the restaurant.
A
Austin B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 22/01/26
• DoorDash order
There was too much of everything in the food but the food itself . The Bucatini Cacio e Pepe was a pepper bomb that was inedible. The Campanelle Shrimp Limone was pretty solid in concept but the citrus flavor is tricky to do in pasta . In this instance, it's very very forward whereas the more successful variations I've had are far more subtle . The Cannoli Chips & Dip were nice to finish but not worth the 15 bucks for a 3 oz ramekin of cannoli cream and a few thin cannoli chips .
All in all , I haven't felt this poorly about a DoorDash decision in a while . My dasher was great and the food was warm, the food was just really disappointing. I don't say this to be dramatic but after I finish typing this , my woman and I are looking at getting food to actually enjoy something we ate tonight .
N
Niki A
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 02/10/26
• DoorDash order
I had dinner here on Wednesday night and the food was amazing. I ordered through door dash and portions are easily half the size. Still good but highly disappointed. I spent $53 on this!
