The Margherita Large 16" pizza was great. Cooked perfectly. The SM Broccoli & Cheese (White)Stromboli had a lot of cheese. No skimping or empty bread. The Homemade Ricotta Cannolis were tasty. Love the breaded French Fries
J
Jess W
9 contributions
Loved
• 10/07/25
• DoorDash order
first timer here! 🙋🏻♀️
We've lived in brookhaven for 11 years and though we've kept them in mind, we always went "delivery route" and not so much doordash etc. I can tell you that their food is worth every amount of hype they are getting. I'll share photos of freshly delivered. We have a family of 5, two out of three of my kiddos are autistic and they devoured it! The Margherita Large 16" was a huge hit! next up is their Classic Cheese Pizza Large 16" also a hit. their Garlic Knots were 10/10, and French Fries always a go to for kiddos. My husband personally loved their Smores Inside Out and the limo LIMONCELLO MASCARPONE CAKE i enjoyed with my Nespresso coffee. 5 shining stars! They won us over 😍🥰
B
Bob M
2 contributions
Loved
• 23/12/25
• DoorDash order
I got breaded Buffalo and mango habanero wings on some DD credit. It was my first time using Poseidon and it did not disappoint. I can't wait to try their pizza and believe they replace one of my other go to pizza places just cause the wings are bigger and the prices are smaller. I dig that!
J
J B
Local Expert • 18 contributions
Loved
• 29/06/24
• DoorDash order
Both the Classic Cheese Pizza Large 16" and the Upside Down 12" was great and the Mozza Luna was some of the best fried mozz/ "sticks" I've had. Good flavor and good chesse pull. Fries were great. Onions Rings were nicely breaded with a ring of whole onion. Everything tasted fresh and was prepared well.
A
Alicia M
2 contributions
Loved
• 09/02/25
• DoorDash order
Our order was delicious! The Vodka Pie Small 12" was a slightly different spin on a classic lizza. We still did get the Classic Cheese Pizza Large 16" for the kids. We also really loved the Buffalo Chicken Pie 12" and the Seasar Salad. Cant wait to order again! This photo is all that is left- shared between 2 families
