According to the Durham Herald-Sun and countless customers, Randy's Pizza serves the greatest New York-style pizza in the Triangle area.
The restaurant is known for its huge pizza slices, with sizes r…
New to town and ive now found "the spot" when I need NY style pizza. Plain cheese, just the right amount of sauce, a little floppy, foldable, with the perfect bit of crunch in the crust. 10/10, and the wings were good too.
A
Andrea N
91 contributions
Didn't like
• 25/05/25
• DoorDash order
The port of the tiram was the sizeof a matchbo car a rip off for $9.10. Pizza was good. Garlic knots are nothing special tasted like they cameout of a frozen food bag
J
Janice G
Local Expert • 160 contributions
Liked
• 30/08/26
• DoorDash order
Enjoyed very much. Fries were hot and perfectly salted, didn't miss the ketchup. Sandwich was great too. I ordered heated but it came not heated...easier to bite into the fresh roll. However the hot fries warmed the sandwich but didn't melt the cheese and allow the oil and vinegar to penetrate the meat and bread. No napkins either. What's a customer to do!
J
Justin T
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 20/12/24
• DoorDash order
Garlic knots are undercooked. Whoever made the pizza has no idea how to make pizza. Pizza is so thin I can see through it. It's too thin to have proper cheese and sauce so thats lacking also. I have al loved Randys pizza but this was a loss
J
Janice G
Local Expert • 160 contributions
Didn't like
• 24/05/26
• DoorDash order
This 8 inch was more like 6 inch. Bread roll is just sligjtly larger than a hot dog bun, meatballs were very small and not much sauce so a little on the dry side. Randy's has really tightened up their offerings. Will be passing up this restaurant going forward. Very disappointed. Maybe a handful of fries would have given some value.
