Rosati’s completely missed the mark by marketing their pie as authentic Chicago pizza when it’s anything but. What arrived was disappointingly thin, virtually stripped of sauce and cheese, and shockingly light on toppings—a far cry from the deep, hearty slice you expect when a place claims the Chicago name. If you're looking for a standard, straightforward pie, sticking to a regular option is fine, but as far as their "Chicago" style goes, it’s an easy skip. Save yourself the letdown and head straight to Vito’s instead.
C
Chris C
Local Expert • 26 contributions
Liked
• 22/08/26
• DoorDash order
18" Pizza - Build Your Own Pizza I just got cheese and it was great. Crust could be thinner. Three Cheese Baked Penne I got this only because I wanted meatballs and it did not come with any despite adding it to my order of pasta. The sauce was watery and leaked all over into the bag. I would not buy the pasta again.
S
Sarah B
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/05/25
• DoorDash order
Terrible dough, got one with double dough and two with thin crust, both were comparable to frozen pizza. Crust turned to powder after biting into. Rosatis used to be a good go-to but like everything else has gotten cheap with their ingredients, but not their prices.
P
Priscilla V
7 contributions
Loved
• 14/04/25
• DoorDash order
Im traveling from out of town and wanted to try something new, it was outstanding!! 10/10 it arrived hot. You can taste the authentic in the sauce.. you wont regret it !!
