I've been ordering from here for 4 months. Never had a bad meal. I order every time the Fire Honey Pie, always cooked to perfection crispy and out right delicious. Also ordered the meatball appetizer with ricotta excellent and tried for the first time Gnocchi & Burrata sauce was a little simple but the burrata makes it taste great so if we are gradung it. Overall score 9/10
Pizza 10/10
Meatballs 10/10
Gnocchi & Burrata 8/10
Fast and hot delivery as well.
I will add a pic of the pizza everything else was eaten already sorry lol
I
Isabel P
2 contributions
Loved
• 04/07/25
• DoorDash order
Gluten Free 10-Inch Pie had an amazing crust & flavor. Had no idea they even had gluten free options here but I love it! I have specific food allergies and they were so kind about making modifications. My friends loved the speciality pies they ordered. Spicy Tito Pie is a 10/10. The food here is amazing! Also got the wrong order originally and they delivered the correct one themselves right away.
J
J J
2 contributions
Liked
• 22/08/24
• DoorDash order
the Fire Honey Pie was the most expensive pizza pie ive ever had hands down but it was so good i was literally licking the grease out of the box. however I do think they could have given more pepperonis like in the pictures. especially for the price. I was more excited for Kirbys Garlic Kirbys Garlic Knots (6), even though i got more than six, which i was excited for when i saw the bag, i wasnt excited to see that they were all burnt. given that it was kind of cold already, i knew they were gonna burn more. unlucky. but 4.5/5 stars!
D
Diana F
2 contributions
Loved
• 08/05/25
• DoorDash order
If you find yourself in Mahopac, make a beeline for Trio Pizza. Treat yourself to a slice (or a whole pie!) of their exceptional Grandma Pie and don't miss out on the decadent pleasure of their Baked Vodka. These two dishes alone are worth the visit and will undoubtedly leave you craving more. Trio Pizza isn't just a pizza place; it's a local favorite that delivers on flavor and quality.
E
Eric T
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 23/05/26
• DoorDash order
The Trio's 'Thinny Thin' Pie is a classic and very well prepared each every time we order it. Taste is very fresh and the portion sizes are Great! We are ordering from this place again. 
