Upper Crust Pizza
4.6(500+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(500+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Experience the flavors of Oyster Bar Winter Haven, where New Orleans charm meets refined coastal cuisine. Now offering our exclusive selection of fresh handcrafted sushi. Enjoy the freshest sushi in t…
Full Menu
11:15 am - 9:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
BYO 18 in
$22.79
•88% (34)
#2 Most liked
BYO 14 in NEW
$17.99
•91% (35)
#1 Most liked
Tye Dye Pie 18 inch
$32.39
Fleetwood Mac n Cheese 18 inch
$32.39
Bee-Gees Knees 14 inch
$25.19
Magic Mushroom 18 inch
$32.39
Reviews500+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
A
Amanda J
3 contributionsLiked
• 15/08/26The Groovy Pie 14 inch was good. Flavors not too overpowering, and crust was well made. Everything tasted fresh. The Tiramisu was way smaller then I expected, but tasted rich and with a creamy bitterness. I'd order the pizza again, but dessert is not a shareable portion. I only eat white sauce so Ill try a different one of those next time. I asked for it to be well done, but it was still a bit soft. I had to throw it in the oven for a few mins. Overall, I recommend this if you like REAL pizza.
T
Tammy W
5 contributionsDidn't like
• 02/09/26Pizza not very flavorful, Groovy pie was soggy and appeared undercooked in center. The sausage Byop was a grease pit. Not as good as another locations I've visited; price was average for brand, possibly high for the area. Will not order again.
M
Mat B
3 contributionsDidn't like
• 01/12/24I ordered a 14 inch BYO pizza, a Red Velvet and Key Lime Pie dessert. Pizza crust was a bit limp. Sauce was decent . The sausage and pepperoni were great. My biggest problem with the pizza was the strong oven taste. It was off putting at first. I did order garlic cheese crust which helped. The desserts definitely tasted frozen, but good anyway. Even though it wasnt spectacular I would still prefer this place over the chain pizza spots. I will give them another chance, but would rather get Palace Pizza before ordering from here
B
Brandon D
5 contributionsLoved
• 17/04/25Best red sauce I have had in Florida. pizza was specular, but the Mariana stole the show. Garlic Bread Sauces BYO 18 in Our new favorite pizza place. 11 out of 10 Highly recommend
S
Suzzanne D
Emerging Expert • 7 contributionsLoved
• 03/05/25BYO 14 cheese pie with ricotta cheese fresh basil red sauce .garlic Parm crust., delicious it's about time we got a good pizza parlor around here in Winter Haven
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store