In 1988, in Hamilton, New Jersey, The Bagel Street Grill began baking oven-fresh bagels. We relocated to Plainsboro in 1995 and have developed deep roots in the community. Our success can be attribute…
I got the Meat, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich on an everything bagel cause that is my usual goto breakfast staple. As expected, it was fresh, very tasty, cooked thoroughly, and absolutely filling. I love me a good bagel sandwich and especially from a local bagel shop/bakery and this didn't disappoint. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll definitely have to order again and try some other things!
D
Drew D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 24/07/26
• DoorDash order
Quality of this placed has fallen off in the last year. It may be new owners. They've nearly doubled their prices and started using lower quality ingredients. The pastrami was absolutely ghastly and had the look and taste of a boiled meat. There are way better delis around here that have better value.
K
Karen D
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Liked
• 29/04/26
• DoorDash review
We order quite frequently from Bagel Street Grill. The steak & eggs breakfast delivers, Hot & well portioned! The side steak is well seasoned & delicious. I would recommend adding extra meat opinion for hearty appetites. Bon Appetite!
A
Alex S
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 25/08/25
• DoorDash order
8 dollars for a breakfast sandwich and there is literally one egg, one slice of cheese, and very little meat. The bread/bagel is 4x the contents of the sandwich, for that price.
You also can't select the bagels for the 1/2 dozen or dozen bagels which is crazy. The bagels are great and would order again, but the breakfast sandwich's are a joke and I would not order them again.
K
Karen D
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
Loved
• 7/01/26
• DoorDash order
Side of the Canadian BaconBagel with Cream Cheese was great as usual. We order quite frequently from Bagel Street & we are normally satisfied with our food. The last order could have been better.Two Egg with Meat Platter was good but we always order extra steak & the last time it wasn't what we normally get when ordering extra. The food is very tasty even if it is a little more expensive than other area bagel shops.
